I seem to go through this every time I buy a pistol that doesn’t fit any of my current holsters. I am very particular when it comes to holsters. Like most people who carry a firearm, I have dozens of holsters. Over the years, I have had:

  • Fanny packs
  • Inside the waistband
  • Outside the waistband
  • Ankle holsters
  • tuckable IWB
  • Thunderwear
  • Pocket Holsters
  • Appendix carry
  • Sneaky Pete
  • Man Purse (OK, shoulder bag)
  • and I am sure others that I can’t remember.

The holsters that I have generally fit guns in the following categories (Yes, nearly all of my carry guns are M&P, because it is easier to buy a holster that fits multiple handguns that way):

  • Large Auto: M&P45, M&P10
  • Midsized Auto: M&P9, M&P40
  • Compact Auto: M&P9c, Glock 19
  • Small Auto: Shield Plus
  • Minicompact: Shield9, Shield40, Shield 45
  • Micro Compact: Bodyguard 380, Beretta 3032
  • Small Revolver: Smith and Wesson 642

Over the years, I have developed a taste for what I like, and for what I don’t like.

For starters, I don’t like the feel of Kydex or other hard plastics against my skin. I find that the plastic finds a spot to dig in, which causes me to fiddle with the holster, moving it around to make it more comfortable. The more you fiddle with a concealed holster, the more obvious it is that you are carrying. That means I want a leather or hybrid holster. A good example of a hybrid holster is an MTAC.

I can and do have a couple of OWB holsters in nylon or Kydex. Leather isn’t as important for me when dealing with off-skin carry. Still, I don’t have a lot of open carry holsters because Florida law doesn’t allow for open carry.

I also don’t like holsters that attach with clips- plastic or metal. They don’t stay secure, and I find that on the draw, the holster tends to come out of your pants with the pistol. For that reason, I like leather straps or belt slots that are cut into the holster itself.

One of the problems that I had when I first began carrying pistols with microdots is there were not any commercial holsters made for them. I wound having to get a custom one from Milt Sparks. The disadvantage was that it took 10 weeks to get my holster. Now the wait for his work is over 40 weeks. That won’t do.

The good news is that there are now many more custom leathermakers who can provide holsters for guns with microdots. One of them is Wright Leatherworks. I like the Banshee, and at $155 for a microdot ready holster with a 10 week lead time is already causing me to think about getting one for the 10mm. Not because I will carry it a lot, but it will give me the option of carrying it if I want to.

The good news is that everything for the 10mm is finally in (except the 5 spare magazines), so a range trip is coming in the next week or two. I will do a function test, and I am planning on buying some ballistic gelatin in the near future. That will allow me to compare some of my carry options in the distant future.

Categories: Guns

4 Comments

Grumpy51 · March 10, 2025 at 7:45 am

Thanks for the info!!

I agree with leather (I carry IWB) and have used https://sobtactical.com/collections/new-leather-section for the past 10 yrs (or so). I have had zero problems with.

EN2 SS · March 10, 2025 at 8:08 am

“I don’t like the feel of Kydex or other hard plastics against my skin.”
When I bought my Sig, I grabbed a kydex holster as a stopgap until I could research/find my best holster. After several tries, I took a small piece of sheepskin, cut it to fit between my body and the inside of my waistband kydex, glued it to the holster and then shaved the wool down thin on the leather. Now I never need to reposition the Sig, I put it in place and the wool makes it disappear to my subconscious. When hot I do not sweat where the holster sits, when cold no chilled spot, works great for me.

SmileyFtW · March 10, 2025 at 8:55 am

I am lucky that my best friend makes custom holsters. If he doesn’t have a pattern model I am only without the pistol for a few days. From settling on a design, color, etc. to delivery is seldom more than a few weeks (sometimes less if he doesn’t have other stuff on his plate).
I don’t have a red dot equipped pistol (yet) so we haven’t gone down that rabbit hole.
The nice thing is that over time we’ve already figured out cant and other nuances.

Thanks for your posts.

Dave Walter · March 10, 2025 at 9:03 am

Surprised to see you mention Wight leather.

A friend and I went to the shop and ordered four holsters. We are picking them up tomorrow.

Shop looks well run and quality seams to be very good. And I have holsters from most of the old school custom markers.

Good luck with the 10 mm. Sonny Crockett got to me early on. I’m glad to see a renewed interest in the caliber.

I’m not connected to Wight Leather in any way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *