The left is all over my Twitter feed, complaining that the St Pete Beach Trolley is being shut down, and blaming Amendment 3 for it.

There are even some on the site claiming that they wanted Amendment 3 to cause pay cuts and eliminatiing “waste” without eliminating necessary things like public transportation.

Look- what one person considers “waste” another will consider essential. That’s how it rolls. Each of us has a different idea of essential. For example: police, fire, roads, and public works are all needed. That doesn’t mean that they can spend whatever they wish. That’s how you get a $75 million gym for police to use.

So back to the trolley. This trolley runs along the beach and is mainly used by tourists. In all, 530,000 people per year ride the trolley. It costs $2.25 per trip for adults. Those over 65 years old get the trip for $1.10 and under 8 years old ride for free. It costs $1.2 million per year to run the trolley, but fares pay for most of it. About $240,000 per year is paid with general fund money.

Do the math: if 530,000 people are riding this trolley each year, but they are collecting less than a million in fares, there are a lot of people riding for free or reduced fares. In fact, they collect about $1.85 per rider. So here is how you keep the trolley running: Increase the fare for everyone to $2.50, no exceptions or carve-outs. That will mean, assuming ridership stays the same, collected fares of $1.33 million, and the trolley will operate in the black without needing taxpayer subsidies.

I can already hear the screeching. “Old people are on a fixed income and can’t afford that.” OK, so they don’t have to ride it. As it is, the current choice is either homeonwers who never ride the trolley and don’t even go to the beachfront area have to pay for it, or they shut it down and no one gets to ride it.

That’s socialism in a nutshell: everyone is poor together.

Categories: economicsTaxes

0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All posts moderated. Rules for posting found here.